84-9-112 through 84-9-116.
OFFICIAL UCC COMMENT
Prior Uniform Statutory Provision:
None.
Purposes:
Under the definition of Section 9-105, in any provisions of the Article dealing with the collateral the term "debtor" means the owner of the collateral even though he is not the person who owes payment or performance of the obligation secured. The section covers several situations in which the implications of this definition are specifically set out.
The duties which this section imposes on a secured party toward such an owner of collateral are conditioned on the secured party's knowledge of the true state of facts. Short of such knowledge he may continue to deal exclusively with the person who owes the obligation. Nor does the section suggest that the secured party is under any duty of inquiry. It does not purport to cut across the law of conversion or of ultra vires. Whether a person who does not own property has authority to encumber it for his own debts and whether a person is free to encumber his property as collateral for the debts of another, are matters to be decided under other rules of law and are not covered by this section.
The section does not purport to be an exhaustive treatment of the subject. It isolates certain problems which may be expected to arise and states rules as to them. Others will no doubt arise: their solution is left to the courts.
This section, which does not vary from the 1995 Official Text, prescribes the duties of the secured party where the owner of the collateral is not the obligor. For the related definition of "debtor," which is broad enough to contemplate the owner of collateral used as collateral for another's debt, see 84-9-105(1)(d). The duties set forth in subsections (a) through (e) are conditioned on the secured party's knowledge that the person who owes the obligation is not the owner of the collateral. The secured party apparently is under no duty of inquiry, but under the provisions of 84-9-203 the security agreement must be signed by the debtor and the debtor must have rights in the collateral. The security agreement would reveal the owner of the collateral in most conceivable cases, absent a subsequent covert sale. This section establishes the governing rules among the third party owner, the true debtor, and the secured party. Most of the duties spelled out in this section relate to the primary obligor's default. The collateral owner gets any surplus from a foreclosure sale, has a right to redeem the collateral, may recover penalties for creditor misbehavior, and gets notification if the secured party proposes to retain the collateral in satisfaction of the debt under 84-9-505. Curiously, this section does not list the right to receive notice of any foreclosure sale under 84-9-504(3), but this omission should be seen as a drafting oversight rather than a limit on the broad definition of "debtor" under 84-9-105(1)(d). For a good case holding that the foreclosing creditor has a duty to notify the hypothecator, see Rushton v. Shea, 423 F. Supp. 468 (D. Del. 1976).
Cross References:
Sections 9-105, 9-208 and Part 5.
Definitional Cross References:
"Collateral". Section 9-105.
"Debtor". Section 9-105.
"Notice". Section 1-201.
"Person". Section 1-201.
"Receive notice". Section 1-201.
"Right". Section 1-201.
"Secured party". Section 9-105.
Revisor's Note:
Former sections 84-9-112 through 84-9-116 were repealed by L. 2000, ch. 142, ยง 155.
KANSAS COMMENT, 1996
This section, which does not vary from the 1995 Official Text, prescribes the duties of the secured party where the owner of the collateral is not the obligor. For the related definition of "debtor," which is broad enough to contemplate the owner of collateral used as collateral for another's debt, see 84-9-105(1)(d). The duties set forth in subsections (a) through (e) are conditioned on the secured party's knowledge that the person who owes the obligation is not the owner of the collateral. The secured party apparently is under no duty of inquiry, but under the provisions of 84-9-203 the security agreement must be signed by the debtor and the debtor must have rights in the collateral. The security agreement would reveal the owner of the collateral in most conceivable cases, absent a subsequent covert sale. This section establishes the governing rules among the third party owner, the true debtor, and the secured party. Most of the duties spelled out in this section relate to the primary obligor's default. The collateral owner gets any surplus from a foreclosure sale, has a right to redeem the collateral, may recover penalties for creditor misbehavior, and gets notification if the secured party proposes to retain the collateral in satisfaction of the debt under 84-9-505. Curiously, this section does not list the right to receive notice of any foreclosure sale under 84-9-504(3), but this omission should be seen as a drafting oversight rather than a limit on the broad definition of "debtor" under 84-9-105(1)(d). For a good case holding that the foreclosing creditor has a duty to notify the hypothecator, see Rushton v. Shea, 423 F. Supp. 468 (D. Del. 1976).
CASE ANNOTATIONS
1. One not privy to security agreement not personally liable for debt. Clark Jewelers v. Satterthwaite, 8 Kan. App. 2d 569, 571, 662 P.2d 1301 (1983).
2. Interest as lessee in growing crops not the same as owner of collateral being foreclosed for third party's debts. First Nat'l Bank v. Milford, 239 Kan. 151, 155, 718 P.2d 1291 (1986).